Pressure on Moscow mounts as more labs confirm Navalny poisoning

The case has prompted international calls for Russia to carry out a transparent investigation or risk sanctions, but the country has not opened a criminal probe.


Two European laboratories have corroborated German findings that Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny was poisoned with a Novichok nerve agent, Berlin said on September 14, prompting French President Emmanuel Macron to demand Vladimir Putin shed light on the "attempted murder".

Hitting back at doubts raised by Russia about the German investigation, Chancellor Angela Merkel's spokesman Steffen Seibert said Germany had asked France and Sweden "for an independent review of the German evidence on the basis of new samples from Mr Navalny", who is receiving treatment in Berlin.

"The results of this review at specialised laboratories in France and Sweden are now available and confirm the German evidence" of the use of the banned weapons-grade substance, Seibert said in a statement.

The new results prompted Macron to tell the Russian president in telephone talks that it was "imperative that all light be shed, without delay, on the circumstances of this attempted murder and who is responsible", the French presidency said in a statement.

Putin fired back that the claims remained "unsubstantiated accusations based on nothing against the Russian side".

Although Germany was still waiting for the outcome of a separate evaluation by the OPCW global chemical weapons watchdog, Seibert said Germany was renewing its call for Russia to make a "declaration on the events".

"We are in close contact with our European partners about further steps," he said.

Asa Scott, head of division for CBRN defence and security at the Swedish Defence Research Agency, confirmed to AFP its lab in Umea in northern Sweden had found Novichok in the sample and presumed it came from Russia.

"I find it unlikely that any other nation that is party to the Chemical Weapons Convention would have it," Scott said.


The 44-year-old Kremlin critic and anti-corruption campaigner became ill after boarding a plane in Siberia last month and was hospitalised there before being flown to Berlin.

Navalny has now emerged from a medically induced coma and is responding to speech, Charite hospital has said.

Germany said two weeks ago there was "unequivocal evidence" that he was poisoned with Novichok but Russia has angrily dismissed the findings, saying its doctors found no trace of poison.

Western politicians have insisted the incident appears likely to have been state-ordered and urged Moscow to prove its lack of involvement. The Kremlin has denounced attempts to blame the Russian state as "absurd".

The case has prompted international calls for Russia to carry out a transparent investigation or risk sanctions, but the country has not opened a criminal probe.

Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said Friday that Russia took offence "when other countries dictate to us what legal procedures we should start and when".

He insisted Russia "de facto" is probing the incident but cannot open a criminal case "on the basis of tests by the German side, especially when carried out in German military labs".

Russia wants to question Navalny at his Berlin hospital, with Siberian transport police, who have been retracing Navalny's movements, saying Friday that Russia would be preparing a request for its officers and an "expert" to shadow German investigators.

- Navalny allies declare victory -

Navalny had been in Siberia to campaign ahead of elections held on Sunday.

Two of his allies won local parliament seats in the city of Tomsk where he fell ill, according to early results released Monday.

The polls came a year ahead of parliamentary elections and were seen as a test for the Kremlin, as the ruling party faces sinking popularity and simmering public anger over economic woes.

Meanwhile the Navalny case has heightened tensions between Russia and the West, and sharpened calls for Germany to abandon the nearly-completed Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline project.

Critics say the multi-billion-euro infrastructure undertaking beneath the Baltic Sea that is set to double Russian natural gas shipments to Germany, Europe's largest economy, would increase dependency on Russia.

Merkel said last week she would not rule out possible consequences for the pipeline if Moscow's response to the Navalny poisoning fails to satisfy Berlin.